Subaru Crosstrek Years to Avoid (Updated)

The Subaru Crosstrek is a popular compact SUV known for its dependability and all-weather capability. It has won the hearts of adventurers and daily commuters alike with its practicality, fuel efficiency, and impressive safety features.

However, not all model years have lived up to the brand’s reputation. Some have faced significant issues that have frustrated owners and resulted in costly repairs. Knowing which years to avoid can save you from unnecessary hassles and expenses.

Subaru Crosstrek Years to Avoid

Not every Subaru Crosstrek model has been trouble-free. Certain years stand out due to recurring mechanical and electrical problems. Understanding these years and the issues they face can help you make an informed decision when considering a Crosstrek. Below, we break down the problematic years and the common complaints associated with each.

2013 Model Year

The 2013 Crosstrek marked the debut of this popular SUV. While it brought many innovative features, it also faced growing pains. One of the most notable issues was excessive oil consumption. Owners frequently reported the need to refill oil between changes, often leading to engine wear if neglected. Additionally, engine stalling was a serious concern. Drivers experienced sudden stalls, sometimes in dangerous situations, raising safety alarms.

The brake light defects further compounded the problems. Faulty brake lights not only caused inconvenience but also posed risks to road safety. Despite being Subaru’s first attempt at the Crosstrek, the 2013 model had more downsides than benefits for many buyers.

2014 Model Year

The following year, 2014, carried over some issues from its predecessor. Excessive oil consumption remained a persistent problem, frustrating owners who expected Subaru’s trademark reliability. On top of that, transmission irregularities plagued the model. Drivers noticed erratic gear shifting, leading to unpredictable performance and, in some cases, costly repairs.

This model year also had a tendency for early transmission wear, further decreasing its appeal. Owners found themselves dealing with higher-than-expected maintenance costs, which made the 2014 Crosstrek less desirable compared to other options.

2016 Model Year

The 2016 Subaru Crosstrek is another year that many owners have found disappointing. While it improved in some areas compared to earlier models, it still had significant issues. One of the most frequently reported problems was electrical failures. Drivers often experienced malfunctions in critical systems, including dimming or flickering lights, which affected visibility and overall safety.

Interior accessories also caused frustration for many. Features like the infotainment system and power steering controls were prone to glitches, leading to an inconvenient and unpredictable driving experience. Some owners reported failures in power steering, which posed serious safety risks, especially at high speeds or in demanding driving conditions.

Another recurring issue with the 2016 Crosstrek was brake performance. Faulty brakes or early brake wear made maintenance a frequent and expensive requirement. Many owners felt these problems diminished the value and reliability Subaru vehicles are typically known for. As a result, the 2016 model is often considered a year to avoid if you’re seeking a trouble-free experience.

2018 Model Year

The 2018 Crosstrek brought a redesign and upgraded features, but it wasn’t without its flaws. The most notable complaint from owners was the windshield. Drivers reported that windshields were unusually fragile, cracking even under minor impacts. This problem was widespread enough to cause significant concern among buyers.

Additionally, the 2018 model faced issues with its Starlink infotainment system. Users frequently reported software crashes, unresponsive touchscreens, and connectivity failures. For a vehicle marketed as tech-forward, these electronic problems were disappointing. Owners often found themselves frustrated by a system that didn’t deliver as promised.

2019 Model Year

The 2019 Subaru Crosstrek built on the momentum of the 2018 redesign but unfortunately inherited some of its predecessor’s flaws. One of the most persistent issues was the fragile windshield. Similar to the 2018 model, the windshield was prone to cracking with minimal impact. This defect resulted in frequent repairs, often frustrating owners who expected better durability.

Another significant concern was engine stalling. Subaru had to issue a recall for the 2019 Crosstrek due to problems with the engine control module. The defect caused the engine to unexpectedly shut down, sometimes while driving, which posed serious safety risks. This problem shook the confidence of many owners who valued Subaru for its reliability.

The 2019 model also experienced complaints about fuel efficiency not meeting expectations. Drivers found that real-world mileage fell short of the advertised figures, adding to the list of disappointments. These combined issues made the 2019 Crosstrek a less appealing choice for those looking for a hassle-free SUV.

Common Issues Across Problematic Years

While each problematic Crosstrek model year has its unique flaws, there are some recurring themes across the board. Recognizing these common problems can help you avoid potential headaches.

Windshield Cracking

Several Crosstrek models, particularly from 2018 and 2019, suffered from fragile windshields. Owners reported cracks forming from minor impacts or even without any apparent cause. This issue led to frequent replacements and added maintenance costs, undermining the vehicle’s overall value.

Excessive Oil Consumption

The 2013 and 2014 models were notorious for consuming more oil than normal. Owners had to check and refill oil frequently, which was not only inconvenient but also led to long-term engine wear if ignored. This issue highlighted a serious design flaw that Subaru later addressed but not before frustrating many early adopters.

Electrical System Failures

Faulty electrical components, such as brake lights and infotainment systems, were common complaints across multiple years. These problems impacted the safety and functionality of the vehicles, with drivers frequently reporting unresponsive controls and unreliable systems.

Frequently Asked Questions (F.A.Q)

What are the most common issues with the Subaru Crosstrek?

The most common issues with the Subaru Crosstrek include excessive oil consumption, fragile windshields, electrical failures, and engine stalling. These problems were particularly prevalent in specific model years, such as 2013, 2014, 2018, and 2019. Addressing these concerns requires careful maintenance or, ideally, avoiding these model years altogether.

Is the Subaru Crosstrek a reliable car?

The Subaru Crosstrek is generally reliable, but some model years have faced recurring problems. Models after 2020 tend to offer improved reliability and better technology. If you’re considering a used Crosstrek, thorough research into its maintenance history is recommended to ensure a trouble-free experience.

Are newer Crosstrek models free from these issues?

Newer Crosstrek models, particularly those released after 2020, have shown significant improvement in reliability. Subaru has addressed many of the earlier flaws, such as excessive oil consumption and fragile windshields. However, regular maintenance and proper care are still essential for optimal performance.

How can I avoid purchasing a problematic Crosstrek?

To avoid purchasing a problematic Crosstrek, steer clear of the highlighted years (2013, 2014, 2016, 2018, and 2019). Always review the vehicle’s service history and consider having it inspected by a trusted mechanic before buying.

Does Subaru offer warranties for common Crosstrek issues?

Subaru has issued recalls and extended warranties for specific problems, such as engine stalling and windshield defects. Checking the vehicle’s recall history with the manufacturer can help you determine if any repairs were covered or still eligible.

Wrapping Up

The Subaru Crosstrek remains a popular choice for its versatility, reliability, and off-road capability. However, not all model years live up to this reputation. Identifying and avoiding problematic years like 2013, 2014, 2016, 2018, and 2019 can save you from potential headaches and costly repairs. Common issues such as excessive oil consumption, fragile windshields, and electrical system failures have plagued these models, making them less appealing for buyers seeking peace of mind.